At CPI, we're always up to something. Here are some past events:
Water poses many challenges to our nation’s electric power system. Water supply is a concern as every day more than 160 billion gallons of fresh and saline water are withdrawn to support various unit operations (e.g., steam cycle makeup water, air scrubbers, cooling water) for thermoelectric power generation, making it the largest withdrawer of water in the United States. The demand for electricity is growing and with it the need to site new capacity, often in locations with limited water supply options. Under extreme drought conditions power plants have been forced off-line due to streamflow/reservoir levels dropping below intake structures or water temperatures exceeding permitted operating conditions. Toward these challenges the Department of Energy has supported several of their National Labs to assist the nation’s three large electric interconnections in integrating water into their long-term transmission planning.
Much of this work is captured in four related studies. The results of these studies were presented over a series of four, 60-minute webcasts. Stakeholders in the industry were invited as panelists to share their perspective on the results.
Monday, October 29, 2018 at 1 pm ET / 10 am PT
Characterization of Power Plant Water Use
Study Description: Estimates of operational water withdrawal and water consumption factors (i.e., gal/MWh) for electricity generating technologies in the United States were developed. Estimates were collected from published primary literature and were not modified except for unit conversions. Estimates were distinguished by fuel type, prime mover, cooling type, emissions controls, and location. More recently, power plant operations have been shown to impact water use through the idling and cycling of power generation.
Friday, November 30, 2018 at 1 pm ET / 10 am PT
Integrated Transmission Planning
Study Description: Consideration of water supply in transmission expansion planning (TEP) provides a valuable means of managing impacts of thermoelectric generation on limited water resources. Toward this opportunity, thermoelectric water intensity factors and water supply availability (fresh and non-fresh sources) were incorporated into a recent TEP exercise conducted for the electric interconnection in the Western United States. The goal was to inform the placement of new thermoelectric generation so as to minimize issues related to water availability. Conduct of this exercise highlighted the importance of integrating water into all phases of TEP, particularly joint management of decisions that are both directly (e.g., water availability constraint) and indirectly (technology or policy constraints) related to future thermoelectric water demand, as well as, the careful selection of scenarios that adequately bound the potential dimensions of water impact.
Monday, December 3, 2018 at 1 pm ET / 10 am PT
Climate Impacts on Thermoelectric Power Generation
Study Description: Performance of 1,080 thermoelectric plants across the contiguous US under future climates (2035–2064) was evaluated. Joint consideration of engineering interactions with climate, hydrology and environmental regulations reveals the region-specific performance of these energy systems. Despite climate–water constraints on individual plants, the current power supply infrastructure shows potential for adaptation to future climates by capitalizing on the size of regional power systems, grid configuration and improvements in thermal efficiencies.
Webinar recording on the NARUC YouTube page.
Monday, December 17, 2018 at 1 pm ET / 10 am PT
Energy for Water
Study Description: While there is clear evidence that energy demands by the water sector are rapidly evolving, there has been no comprehensive effort to project these changes into the future. To fill this gap, energy to provide water services was mapped at the regional, state and county level for the contiguous U.S. This study estimated electricity use in 2012 and project to 2032 for large-scale conveyance, agricultural pumping, drinking water and wastewater services. These projections are important for forecasting future energy loads posed by the water sector and for identifying regions where rapid change is possible.
The four workshops took place between September and November 2018.
Wednesday, November 14 | 12:30 - 5:30 pm
At this interactive workshop, state regulators and market stakeholders discussed ways to use DERs to improve resilience in both restructured and vertically integrated states. The discussion focused on intersections between state regulators and bulk power system operators, developed policy options to advance resilient DERs, and established connections between stakeholders to continue this important conversation.
August 14, 2018
Innovation is crucial in the electricity industry. As regulated utilities, power companies have to balance safe, reliable, affordable service with new products, technologies, and services to meet evolving customer needs. Utility regulators have an important role in encouraging innovation and learning from experimentation. In this webinar, speakers from two regulated utilities shared their perspectives on incorporating innovative pilot programs into utility business models. Two experts in pilot design and evaluation offered guidance for regulators and utilities to design pilot programs to maximize learning potential and create lasting benefits for ratepayers.
Moderator: Hon. John Rosales, Illinois
August 10, 2018
Following National Dig Safely Day on August 11, we are all reminded of the importance of safe excavation practices. Pipeline safety is a shared responsibility requiring the cooperation of federal and state regulators, local government entities, contractors, and homeowners. On August 10, 2018, Wyoming Public Service Commission Deputy Chair Kara Brighton Fornstrom moderated a discussion of cooperative federalism in pipeline safety regulation. Sam Hall, senior program manager for the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration’s Office of Pipeline Safety, provided state regulators with an overview of the administration’s November 2017 final rule on excavation damage prevention law enforcement and how PHMSA determines state adequacy. Jason Montoya, bureau chief at the New Mexico Public Regulation Commission’s Pipeline Safety Bureau and chairman of the National Association of Pipeline Safety Representatives, provided a state perspective on implementing the new rules, obtaining and maintaining adequacy, and other state efforts to work closely with the federal government to improve pipeline safety.
Denver, Colorado | Tuesday, May 8, and Wednesday, May 9, 2018
NCEP’s successful annual meeting and workshop explored this evolution and specifically the impact that distributed energy resources (DERs) are and will have on the transmission and distribution systems in the contexts of planning, operations, and markets at the state level. Such DERs as energy efficiency, distributed generation (e.g., solar photovoltaics), energy storage, demand response, electric vehicles, and more, illustrated current examples of technologies and decisions that are underway.
NCEP members in attendance included directors and staff of public utility regulatory agencies, environmental and air regulatory agencies, consumer advocate offices, state legislative bodies, state energy offices, and gubernatorial energy offices. The varied audience reflected NCEP’s membership, who are responsible for state-level electricity policy across the U.S.
Monday, April 9, 2018 | 3:00 - 4:00 pm EST
NARUC’s Center for Partnerships & Innovation and the Staff Subcommittee on Energy Resources and the Environment convened a state commission staff “surge” call, on which state staff from Hawaii, Washington, Indiana, Ohio, and Rhode Island discussed different distribution system planning (DSP) strategies. Across these five states, there are some clear similarities in goals of DSP: multiple staff cited pursuing least-cost solutions, achieving renewable portfolio goals, and providing the most current information as DSP objectives. Commission staff agree on the importance of stakeholder engagement, improving transparency, and educating commissioners, commission staff, utilities, and others involved in the process. However, states diverge in the paths to these objectives.
Tuesday, April 10 | 2:00 - 3:00 pm EDT
Many policymakers expressed optimism when the improved section 45Q tax credits for carbon capture, storage, and utilization were passed in the 2018 budget bill earlier this year. Do financers and project developers share this optimism? Is section 45Q enough to spur investments in new projects? Members of the Carbon Capture Coalition gave their perspectives to NARUC members in this discussion.
Tuesday, March 27 | 2:00 - 3:00 pm EDT
The 2018 budget bill expanded and extended section 45Q tax credits for carbon capture, storage, and utilization - but will this assistance lead to new deployments, and what else is needed to spur investment in carbon capture? Join members of the State CO2-EOR Working Group as they discuss the changes to the tax credits and where they fit in to the policy landscape for carbon capture. A follow-up webinar on April 10 will feature industry members of the Carbon Capture Coalition giving their perspective on how the tax credits improve the economics of carbon capture and move the next wave of projects from concept to reality.
Tuesday, February 27 | 2:00 - 3:00 pm EST
Seventeen elements in the middle of the periodic table, known as rare earth elements (REEs), are critical ingredients in everything from smartphones and MRIs to radar and weapons systems. China produces nearly all of the $5 billion global market for REEs, posing economic and national security risks to the U.S. To counter these risks, the National Energy Technology Lab has funded a portfolio of research projects studying the feasibility of extracting REEs from coal and coal byproducts, including a project at West Virginia University's Water Research Institute to develop a cost-effective method to treat and recover REEs from coal-fired power plants' acid mine drainage. Dr. Paul Ziemkiewicz leads the project and addressed NARUC members on his team's findings so far and the future of their work.
Monday, October 2, 2017 | 3:00 - 4:00 pm EST
The Great Plains Institute State CO2-EOR Deployment Work Group released a white paper in June 2017 taking a detailed look at how carbon capture can compete in vertically integrated and restructured electricity markets. On this webinar, members of the work group discussed the paper with a specific eye towards public utility commissions and state power sector policies.
Monday, September 18, 2017 | 2:00 - 3:00 pm EST
With rapid growth in DER installations, utilities and commissions are paying closer attention to the capability of the distribution grid to handle these additional resources. State commission staff from Michigan, California, and Minnesota provided an udpate on where each state is in reassessing distribution system planning policies to integrate DERs.
Houston, Texas | September 22, 2017
State commissioners and staff went on a site visit to the Petra Nova carbon capture for enhanced oil recovery (CO2-EOR) project at the W.A. Parish Plant in Thompsons, Texas, southwest of Houston. Petra Nova is the world's largest post-combustion carbon capture facility and the leading example of carbon capture technology in the U.S. The project captures over 5,000 tons of carbon dioxide per day from a 240-MW coal unit and transports the gas via pipeline to an oilfield, where it is pumped underground for enhanced oil recovery and permanent sequestration. Commissioners and staff spent September 22 touring the facility and hearing presentations from NRG project staff before returning home.
Please contact Kiera Zitelman to receive information about future site visits through the Carbon Capture, Storage & Utilization Partnership. Travel assistance may be available.
Thursday, September 7, 2017
Technological advancements, market forces, evolving customer needs and desires, and state policies and objectives are driving fundamental changes in today’s electricity system. These changes bring challenges as well as opportunities. On this webinar, hear how your fellow states are responding to those challenges and opportunities. From performance based regulation (PBR) to rate design to advanced metering to DER ownership and beyond, this webinar touches on a number of different, often interrelated grid modernization issues, with examples of how different states across the country (including perhaps yours!) are thinking about them. Our guest speaker for this webinar is Hannah Polikov, Director, Public Utility Commission Program at Advanced Energy Economy.
Thursday, August 17 | 1:00 - 2:00 pm EDT
NARUC and the U.S. Department of Energy's Office of Energy Policy and Systems Analysis collaborated to research the links between large electricity rate or bill increases and public utility commissioner tenure. Through a series of interviews with former regulators and statistical analysis of electricity prices and regulator tenure, we examined whether rising rates leads to fired commissioners and what other circumstances might affect public outcry over rate increases. We invite interested commissioners and staff to hear our conclusions and offer feedback for improving the paper when it is released as a final product in September 2017.
Tuesday, July 11 | 3:00 - 4:00 pm EST
Passed in the aftermath of the 1973 energy crisis, the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act (PURPA) has now been in effect for nearly four decades. Despite a few PURPA amendments and multiple, broad changes in electricity markets, most states have not significantly updated their PURPA rules and buy-back rates since fairly soon after the law was passed. As a result, large and small qualifying facilities (QFs, in PURPA-speak), including renewable-powered generators and particularly distributed generation, could still have difficulty gaining the market foothold PURPA was initially designed to enable. Several states are reexamining PURPA implementation in light of current conditions. Join state public utility commission staff from Michigan, Oregon, Montana, and Massachusetts to discuss each state's approach to updating PURPA rules and where these efforts might lead the electricity sector.
Friday, June 23 | 2:30 - 3:30 pm EST
This webinar will serve as an introduction to what Blockchain is, and how it’s been used in financial markets as well as the potential for use in energy markets. Use cases such as the LO3 project will be discussed. We will also learn about the Illinois government’s perspective, the current stage of the market, and the Illinois Blockchain Initiative. We’ll hear from experts Lawrence Orsini from the LO3 Project as well as Jennifer O’Rourke at the Illinois Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity. The discussion will be led by Commissioner Nick Wagner from the Iowa Utilities Board.
The Lab ran MegaModel: A Utility Business Model Interactive for attendees at three conferences in June. This game puts players in control of an investor-owned utility under one of four different business models. Players then invest in a broad menu of transmission, distribution, and generation resource options and choose policies to meet upcoming demand while chasing performance goals for customer bills, environmental performance, shareholder returns, and reliability. Retiring generation, heat waves, environmental policies, and natural gas price spikes make the game even more challenging.
National Association of State Utility Consumer Advocates Mid-Year Meeting | June 4 - 7 | Denver, Colorado
National Conference of State Legislatures & National Association of State Energy Officials Solar Workshop and Lab | June 9 - 10 | San Antonio, Texas
Mid-Atlantic Conference of Regulatory Utility Commissioners Annual Education Conference | June 25 - 28 | Hershey, Pennsylvania
Additionally, Lab staff offered an electricity siting training to New England commissioners at the New England Conference of Public Utilities Commissioners Symposium, June 4 - 7 in Bretton Woods, New Hampshire.
Interested in bringing MegaModel or a siting training to your state? Contact Lab director Miles Keogh.
Tuesday, May 30 | 2:00 pm EDT
Cybersecurity has become increasingly important to energy regulators due to the potential for adverse reliability impacts from a cyber breach. Over the past several years, the energy sector has been a prime target of cybersecurity incidents, and to combat this, public-private partnerships are engaged in efforts to increase preparedness, response, and recovery. The intent of this webinar is to create foundational knowledge about cybersecurity approaches used in the natural gas sector, and how these approaches compare with the electric sector. We will be joined by Kimberly Denbow from the American Gas Association (AGA), who will share her insight on questions including:
Monday, May 15 | 1:00 pm EDT
The NARUC/DOE Carbon Capture, Storage & Utilization Partnership and the Great Plains Institute’s State Carbon Dioxide for Enhanced Oil Recovery (CO2-EOR) Deployment Work Group offered a webinar on infrastructure policy related to carbon capture projects. Putting CO2 to work in enhanced oil recovery can be a win-win scenario for fossil fuel-fired electricity generators, oil producers, and environmentalists alike. However, a strong network of CO2 pipelines is critical to the future of CO2-EOR projects in an era of low oil prices and uncertain federal climate policy. While CO2-EOR is not a new prospect, the recent success of CO2-EOR projects like NRG’s Petra Nova facility combined with Washington, DC’s focus on domestic energy production and infrastructure has brought renewed attention to CO2-EOR infrastructure needs, particularly how federal and state policy can address weaknesses.
On this webinar, state officials discussed how CO2-EOR projects operate, the state of the nation’s existing CO2 infrastructure, current federal and state policies relevant to CO2-EOR, and recommendations for strengthening CO2 infrastructure. Matt Mead, policy advisor in the Office of the Wyoming Governor; Dan Lloyd, business development specialist in the Office of the Montana Governor; and Shawn Shurden, commission counsel for the Mississippi Public Service Commission joined the webinar as panelists with Brad Crabtree of the Great Plains Institute as moderator.
April 25, 2017 | 2:00 p.m. EDT
The electric grid is exposed to many threats that have the potential to affect reliability. Space weather events is one threat that can cause significant long-term effects on critical infrastructure systems and technologies. Extreme space weather has the potential to shut down large sections of the grid, resulting in cascading failures in many other critical infrastructure sectors that we depend on for health and safety. During this webinar we will discuss what space weather is and how it can affect the power grid. The discussion will be led by experts John Ostrich from DOE and Mark Olson from NERC. Our speakers will share their insights on the following questions:
March 28, 2017 | 3:00 p.m. EDT
The NARUC/DOE Natural Gas Infrastructure Modernization Partnership is extending an invite to NARUC membership and interested stakeholders to participate in a webinar on underground natural gas storage. The webinar will focus on the DOE/PHMSA Interagency Task Force on Natural Gas Storage Safety’s final report on the Aliso Canyon natural gas leak and resulting actions. Participants from both agencies will cover a brief introduction to natural gas storage regulation; specifics of the Aliso Canyon leak and response; implications for electric system reliability and the gas/electric market; recommendations to advance well integrity, health and environmental protection, and gas/electric reliability; and the status of PHMSA’s December 2016 interim final rule revising federal pipeline safety regulations.
This webinar is part of a series of webinars under the Natural Gas Infrastructure Modernization Partnership (NGIMP) with NARUC and DOE.
March 24, 2017
NARUC's Lab hosted a call on March 24, 2017, as part of our "surge" effort to link state staffers to learn from each other. This call focused on how various state commissions are considering the costs and benefits of energy storage. This document summarizes presentations from Hawaii, Washington, Oregon, and Arizona commission staffers and discussion among other state staffers.
March 23, 2017 | 3:00 p.m. EDT
The DOE/NARUC Carbon Capture Storage & Utilization Partnership invites interested state commissioners, state and federal staff, and other stakeholders to learn about the Petra Nova carbon capture project at W.A. Parish Generating Station in Thompsons, Texas. A joint venture between NRG and JX Nippon, Petra Nova enters the market as clean coal and carbon capture technology continue to factor into the national debate on energy and infrastructure. David Greeson, VP of Development at NRG, will discuss the conception, design, and construction of the project as well as its first few months of successful operation as a post-combustion carbon capture for enhanced oil recovery facility before taking questions from the audience.
Webinar presentation and recording are available to NARUC members. Please contact Kiera Zitelman to request.
February 6, 2017
NARUC's Lab hosted a call on February 6, 2017, as part of our "surge" effort to link state staffers to learn from each other. This call focused on carbon trading programs in the northeast and California: the conception and structure of these programs and their future potential for continued operation or expansion. This document summarizes presentations from Maryland and California staffers and discussion among other state staffers.
January 5, 2017 | Baltimore, Maryland
Participants will explore how baseload power gets incorporated into what consumers pay, impacts of the changing generation fleet on valuation pricing, and how state officials can address this change. Participants will identify tools and techniques that attribute value to baseload and develop recommendations and “asks” to research institutions, national laboratories and academia.
December 22, 2016
NARUC CPI team members Miles Keogh & Sharon Thomas ran a webcast about a new primer that the NARUC Lab issued in winter 2016 that introduces risk management tools and concepts for regulators who may not be specialists in that area. Watch it here!
December 15, 2016 | 3:30 p.m. EDT
MIT presented their Utility of the Future study report for Commissioners and Staff. The study presents "a framework for proactive regulatory, policy & market reforms." The presenation describes five key recommendations and steps to take to meet those objectives. The study acknowledges that a "future" described the report is looking out about ten years from now and focuses on the US and Europe.
September 9, 2016
The NARUC Research Lab convened state public utility commission staffers on a "surge" technical assistance call to learn from one another about how much utilities should be spending on information technology (IT) investments.
September 23, 2016
State staff came together for a technical assistance "surge" to explore enhanced oil recovery (EOR), and the implications for state regulators. We summarized the information-sharing that happened in this summary, and it's well worth a read if you want a starting point for understanding how state agencies understand and address this policy topic.
August 4, 2016 | 12:00 p.m. EDT
New York State Public Service Commission commissioner Hon. Diane X. Burman, and Andy Wells, PG&E’s Manager of Gas First Responder Programs with the Public Safety Emergency Preparedness Group, discuss the importance of the Gold Shovel Dig Safe program, and provide options for promoting them at the State level.
July 14, 2016 | 2:00 p.m. EDT
This NARUC Research Lab webinar covers transmission technologies that let you increase power flows and lower line losses without needing to site any new right of way or even install new towers. This award winning technology has been around a while and was developed to improve high temperature performance, and was used to replace an American Electric Power (AEP) line in Texas without de-energizing the line.
Monday, July 11, 2016 | 1:00 p.m. EDT
With the rapid growth in production of natural gas and associated liquids across the country, this webinar will explore the economic development opportunities and challenges associated with this abundant resource and the infrastructure needed to safely transport it. Come gain understanding of the Natural Gas Liquids being produced, and the issues surrounding the development of this valuable commodity beyond just electric power generation.
You are invited to join New York Commissioner Diane X. Burman, Chair of the Natural Gas Infrastructure Modernization Partnership as she moderates a conversation between Pennsylvania Commissioner Rob Powelson and Dr. James Bradbury, Senior Policy Advisory for Climate, Environment & Efficiency, Office of Energy Policy and Systems Analysis, US Department of Energy.
This webinar is the first of a series of webinars under the Natural Gas Infrastructure Modernization Partnership (NGIMP) with NARUC and DOE.
July 8, 2016 | 2:00 p.m. EDT
In the past, Information Technology (IT) and Operational Technology (OT) systems were kept fairly separate. IT was traditionally associated with back-office systems including accounting, billing, HR records, and customer data. OT was traditionally associated with field devices and the systems to monitor and control them such as Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) and distribution management systems (DMS). These technologies were developed in silos because they were managed by separate departments that had different objectives. However, with technological advancements over the years, convergence of IT and OT has been taking place and there are quantifiable benefits to utility companies as well as customers. We will joined by John McDonald of General Electric and Daniel Ohlendorf of Pacific Gas and Electric in a panel-style discussion moderated by Andrew Bochman of Idaho National Laboratory. The panelists will provide insight into how utilities can leverage this convergence for smarter, more cost-effective, and more reliable operation.
You will learn what convergence of the IT and OT means, what advancements have been made as a result of utilities addressing internal IT/OT issues, what some of the security implications of greater convergence are, and more!
July 6, 2016 | Washington, D.C.
Is your utility company using the NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) to help manage its cyber risks? If so, come to the NIST/NARUC workshop on the NIST CSF in Washington, DC on July 6th and 7th. This training aims to help utility regulators understand how the NIST CSF supports the regulatory ecosystem.
Workshop Objectives Include:
June 27, 2016 | 1:00 p.m. EDT
The pace of smart inverter implementation is making waves in many states and now is the time to be informed on what you, the regulatory staff, should know! Smart inverters piqued states interest after Germany experienced blackouts due to voltage controls for distributed energy resources. Now, the technology is experiencing rapid development and standardization.
Here to help understand one states’ point of view, California staffers will share their experience during the collaboration to develop Rule 21, the current status of implementation, and what the future may hold for this tariff as a policy tool and smart inverters as a deployable technology. They will also address some of the “hindsight is 20/20” questions that they wish they knew a few years ago.
Participation is encouraged (and potentially mandatory for anyone that knows Miles!). The phones will be open for participants to ask questions, contribute their experiences, and gain a situational awareness of your fellow states.
June 14, 2016 | Bismarck, North Dakota
NARUC’s Clean Coal and Carbon Management Subcommittee hosted a site visit in conjunction with the Mid-America Regulatory Conference in Bismarck, North Dakota, Tuesday, June 14, 2016. Attendees toured Basin Electric’s Dakota Gasification Company, where lignite coal (the youngest coal, geologically) is gasified and turned into synthetic natural gas, syngas. Dakota Gasfication is America’s largest carbon sequestration project and pipes CO2 north to Canada, where it is used for enhanced oil recovery. Forty MARC attendees learned all the products that can be created from lignite, and about the mining process and mine remediation at the nearby lignite mine.
Joint NARUC Lab Workshop with the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL)
May 25 - 26, 2016 | Denver, Colorado
Cyberattacks on the power grid on your mind? Worried about miscreants messing with the transmission system? The possibility of earthquakes got you losing sleep? We're working with our friends at NCSL to explore what the right risk-based tools will be to deal with threats to the grid that we've never had to deal with before. A two day workshop for Legislature and Commission personnel (especially staff) will give you what you need to make informed decisions. It will also feature one of our world-famous "game" style interactives.
The Magnolia Hotel, Denver Colorado, 8 am Mountain on May 25 until 1 pm on May 26.
Need more information? Please contact Sharon Thomas at email@example.com.
National Council on Electricity Policy Meeting
April 25 - 26, 2016 | Washington D.C.
Essential EISPC work was conducted and we mapped out what technical assistance support from labs, academia, and others will help us deal with changes in jurisdiction.
Dupont Circle Hotel, Washington DC, 12 pm Eastern on April 25 until 3 pm Eastern on April 26th.
Need more information? Please contact Jan Brinch at firstname.lastname@example.org.